What Counts as Terroristic Threats in Pennsylvania?

Under 18 Pa.C.S. 2706(a), you commit terroristic threats in Pennsylvania if you communicate a threat to commit any crime of violence with intent to terrorize another, a threat to cause the evacuation of a building, place of assembly or transit facility, or a threat that causes terror or serious public inconvenience with reckless disregard of that risk. Under 2706(d), the offense is a first-degree misdemeanor, or a third-degree felony when the threat diverts the occupants of a building, place of assembly or transit facility from their normal operations.
In Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), the U.S. Supreme Court held that the First Amendment requires proof of at least recklessness in a true threat prosecution, meaning the state must show the speaker "consciously disregarded a substantial risk that his communications would be viewed as threatening violence." Pennsylvania's statute writes its mental states into the text: 2706(a)(1) requires intent to terrorize, and 2706(a)(3) covers a threat made "with reckless disregard of the risk of causing such terror or inconvenience," wording the Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld against a First Amendment challenge in In the Interest of J.J.M. in December 2021, before Counterman was decided. This article covers the statute, the proof required, penalties, restitution, related arrest and custody rules, and where cases are handled in Westmoreland, Indiana and Fayette counties.

What Does 18 Pa.C.S. 2706 Make a Crime?
A terroristic threat, under Pennsylvania law, is a threat communicated to someone "either directly or indirectly" that fits one of three categories in 18 Pa.C.S. 2706(a):
A threat to commit any crime of violence with intent to terrorize another
A threat to cause evacuation of a building, place of assembly or facility of public transportation
A threat to otherwise cause serious public inconvenience, or to cause terror or serious public inconvenience with reckless disregard of the risk of doing so
The statute defines "communicates" in 2706(e) as conveying a threat "in person or by written or electronic means, including telephone, electronic mail, Internet, facsimile, telex and similar transmissions." A voicemail, a text, an email or an online post falls within that definition just as a face-to-face statement does.
For the threat of violence version in (a)(1), the Superior Court restated the elements in Commonwealth v. Demulter, 2024 PA Super 86, quoting earlier case law. The Commonwealth must prove that the defendant "made a threat to commit a crime of violence" and that "the threat was communicated with the intent to terrorize another."
What Mental State Does the Commonwealth Have to Prove?
The required mental state depends on the subsection charged: intent to terrorize under (a)(1), or reckless disregard of the risk of causing terror or serious public inconvenience under (a)(3).
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the reckless standard in In the Interest of J.J.M., decided December 21, 2021. The court held that the First Amendment allows a conviction under 2706(a)(3) based on reckless disregard. In the same decision, it vacated a student's juvenile adjudication after concluding that his remarks, made in a school hallway, did not cross the line from protected speech to an unprotected true threat.
Counterman, decided June 27, 2023, set the national floor: the state must prove the defendant had some subjective understanding of the threatening nature of the statements, and recklessness is enough. The opinion treats purpose and knowledge as more demanding standards that the Constitution does not require.
Two published Superior Court decisions since Counterman, Demulter in 2024 and Commonwealth v. McGraw, 2025 PA Super 194, analyze the mental state using the statute's own terms and Pennsylvania precedent, and neither opinion cites Counterman. McGraw described the standard as intent to terrorize or reckless disregard for the risk of causing terror, and affirmed a conviction based on statements made to officers serving a mental health warrant.
Can Words Said in Anger Count as Terroristic Threats?
Pennsylvania courts have said the statute is not meant to punish spur of the moment threats that come from anger. The Superior Court repeated that limit in Demulter, quoting Commonwealth v. Campbell, a 2021 Superior Court decision.
Anger alone does not end the inquiry. The same opinion quotes Commonwealth v. Walls for the rule that "Being angry does not render a person incapable of forming the intent to terrorize." The courts look at the surrounding facts:
In Demulter, the court found the threat was not the result of transitory anger, and it considered that the person threatened had earlier seen the defendant attack someone else.
In McGraw, the court pointed to statements made unprovoked, after several minutes of calm, while the defendant was restrained.
Two other points are not elements of the offense. Demulter, citing In re B.R. (Pa. Super. 1999), says that neither the ability to carry out the threat nor the threatened person's belief that it would be carried out is an element, although both can be considered as part of the totality of the circumstances.
What Are the Penalties for Terroristic Threats in Pennsylvania?
Grading under 2706(d) turns on what the threat caused. The base offense is a first degree misdemeanor. It becomes a third degree felony when the threat causes the occupants of a building, place of assembly or facility of public transportation "to be diverted from their normal or customary operations."
The maximum penalties come from the grading and sentencing sections of the Crimes Code:
First degree misdemeanor: up to five years in prison under 18 Pa.C.S. 1104(1) and 106(b)(6), and a fine of up to $10,000 under 18 Pa.C.S. 1101(4)
Third degree felony: up to seven years in prison under 18 Pa.C.S. 1103(3) and 106(b)(4), and a fine of up to $15,000 under 18 Pa.C.S. 1101(3)
These are statutory maximums. The sentence in a particular case depends on the court, the sentencing guidelines and the facts. For comparison with the assault offenses, What Is the Difference Between Simple and Aggravated Assault in Pennsylvania? walks through how each assault offense is graded and the maximum penalty for each grade.
Who Pays for an Evacuation Caused by a Threat?
Section 2706(b) says a person convicted under the statute "shall" be sentenced to pay restitution equal to the cost of the evacuation. The statute lists costs "including, but not limited to" fire and police response, emergency medical service or emergency preparedness response, and transportation of people out of the building, place of assembly or facility.
That restitution is in addition to any other sentence and any restitution ordered under 42 Pa.C.S. 9721(c). Because the statute uses "shall," restitution for evacuation costs is a required part of the sentence once there is a conviction.
Section 2706(c) keeps civil remedies open. A restitution order does not stop a person from suing the offender, but any civil award is reduced by the amount already paid under the criminal judgment.
What Happens When the Threat Involves a Family or Household Member?
A terroristic threats charge against a family or household member carries its own arrest rule. Under 18 Pa.C.S. 2711(a), a police officer has the same right to arrest without a warrant as in a felony case when the officer has probable cause to believe the person violated 2706 against a family or household member, even though the offense did not happen in the officer's presence. The officer must first observe recent physical injury to the victim or other corroborative evidence. Under 2711(b), the arresting officer "shall seize all weapons used by the defendant in the commission of the alleged offense."
What Happens If You Violate a PFA in Pennsylvania? explains a separate warrantless arrest rule for protection order violations, along with the indirect criminal contempt charge and its penalties.
A conviction can also reach a later custody case. Under 23 Pa.C.S. 5329(a), when a party seeks any form of custody, the court must consider whether that party or a member of the party's household has been convicted of, or pleaded guilty or no contest to, a listed offense, and the list includes 2706. The court must consider that conduct and determine that the party does not pose a threat of harm to the child before making any custody order to that party.
Where Are Terroristic Threats Cases Handled in Westmoreland, Indiana and Fayette Counties?
Each county has a Clerk of Courts office at its courthouse:
Westmoreland County: the Clerk of Courts is at the Westmoreland County Courthouse, 2 North Main Street, Suite 203, Greensburg.
Indiana County: one combined office, the Prothonotary and Clerk of Courts, sits on the first floor of the Indiana County Courthouse at 825 Philadelphia Street in Indiana. Its criminal division offers online payment of court costs, fines and fees, criminal records searches and expungement information.
Fayette County: the Clerk of Courts is on the first floor of the Fayette County Courthouse, 61 East Main Street, Uniontown.
The Fayette County Clerk of Courts lists its criminal duties as including "Assessment, collection, and distribution of fines, costs and restitution," processing bail, and recording all criminal case filings, including verdicts and sentences. That covers restitution ordered as part of a sentence, such as evacuation costs under 2706(b).
Bail, the preliminary hearing and arraignment in the Court of Common Pleas are outlined in What Should You Do After an Arrest in PA?.
Bolkovac Law Offices has offices in the same three towns as these courthouses: Greensburg at 207 South Maple Avenue, Indiana at 9 South 7th Street and Uniontown at 92 East Main Street, plus Murrysville at 4559 Old William Penn Highway. The same phone number, 724-837-2626, reaches all four.
FAQ
Can a text message or social media post be a terroristic threat?
Yes, if it meets the other elements. Section 2706(e) defines "communicates" to include written and electronic means such as telephone, electronic mail and the Internet, so sending a threat online or by text does not take it outside the statute. The Commonwealth still has to prove a threat and the required mental state.
Does the person have to be able to carry out the threat?
No. In Demulter, the Superior Court, citing In re B.R., said neither the ability to carry out the threat nor the threatened person's belief that it would happen is an element of the offense. Both can still be weighed with the other circumstances.
What if the threat was meant as a joke?
The text of 2706 has no joke exception, so the question becomes mental state. The Commonwealth must prove intent to terrorize under (a)(1) or reckless disregard under (a)(3), and Counterman requires at least recklessness for a true threat. In J.J.M., the Pennsylvania Supreme Court vacated a student's adjudication after finding that his remarks were not true threats.
Is terroristic threats a felony in Pennsylvania?
It can be. Section 2706(d) makes it a first degree misdemeanor unless the threat diverts the occupants of a building, place of assembly or facility of public transportation from their normal or customary operations, which raises it to a third degree felony with a maximum of seven years in prison.
How long does the Commonwealth have to file terroristic threats charges?
Five years. 42 Pa.C.S. 5552(b)(1) lists 2706 among the offenses for which a prosecution "must be commenced within five years after it is committed," compared with the two year general rule in 5552(a).
Can a terroristic threats conviction be sealed in Pennsylvania?
A misdemeanor conviction may be eligible. 18 Pa.C.S. 9122.1 allows a petition for limited access for certain misdemeanors after a period of seven years free from conviction. Subsection (b)(1)(i) bars limited access for offenses involving danger to the person that carry more than two years in prison, but it states that this bar "shall not apply to a misdemeanor offense under section 2706 (relating to terroristic threats)." Whether a petition fits a given record depends on the other conditions in the statute. Can I Get My Criminal Record Expunged in PA? explains how expungement petitions move through the county Court of Common Pleas and how expungement differs from sealing.
What happens if a threat causes a school or building evacuation?
A threat to cause evacuation is its own form of the offense under 2706(a)(2). If it diverts the occupants from their normal or customary operations, 2706(d) grades it as a third degree felony, and 2706(b) requires restitution for evacuation costs such as police, fire and emergency medical response.
Talk to a Criminal Defense Attorney at Bolkovac Law Offices
Bolkovac Law Offices was founded by Mark D. Bolkovac, who was admitted to practice in Pennsylvania in 2002 and appointed to the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing in January 2024. The firm's criminal defense practice works from offices in Greensburg, Indiana, Murrysville and Uniontown, with free telephone consultations and walk-ins available.
Visit Bolkovac Law Offices or call 724-837-2626 today. Contact us for more information.
The information in this article is for general information purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different and outcomes depend on the specific facts involved. To discuss your situation, contact Bolkovac Law Offices at 724-837-2626.





Comments