top of page

Limited Tort vs Full Tort in Pennsylvania: What Is the Difference?

Writer: Bolkovac Law
Bolkovac Law
Nov 6
6 min read

In Pennsylvania, limited tort lets you recover medical bills and other out-of-pocket losses after a car crash but bars pain and suffering damages unless your injury counts as a "serious injury," while full tort keeps your right to seek pain and suffering in any case. The choice comes from 75 Pa.C.S. 1705, and the statute's own notice says that if you do not sign and return the tort election form, you are treated as having chosen full tort and are charged the full tort premium.

 

Under 75 Pa.C.S. 1705(d), a limited tort insured keeps full rights against a driver who is convicted of DUI or who accepts Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) for DUI, so the at-fault driver's entry into ARD, which is not a conviction, still opens the door to pain and suffering damages. The same section covers crashes with a vehicle registered in another state and injuries suffered while riding in something other than a private passenger vehicle. This post explains both options, what "serious injury" means, every statutory exception and how your choice affects the people in your household.


Bolkovac Law - Blog Header

What Is Limited Tort in Pennsylvania?

 

Limited tort is a lower-cost car insurance option in which you give up the right to recover pain and suffering and other nonmonetary damages unless your injuries meet the statute's serious injury definition or an exception applies. The notice required by 1705(a) says limited tort insureds "may seek recovery for all medical and other out-of-pocket expenses, but not for pain and suffering or other nonmonetary damages" without a serious injury.

 

What you keep matters as much as what you give up. With limited tort you can still pursue economic losses such as medical expenses and lost wages from an at-fault driver.

 

What Is Full Tort in Pennsylvania?

 

Full tort keeps your unrestricted right to sue an at-fault driver for both economic losses and noneconomic losses, which 75 Pa.C.S. 1702 defines as "pain and suffering and other nonmonetary detriment." There is no injury threshold to meet.

 

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department's auto insurance guide sums up the tradeoff: limited tort "offers you significant savings on your premium" but restricts recovery of damages such as pain and suffering unless an exception applies, while "with full tort, you have unrestricted rights."

 

What Counts as a Serious Injury Under Limited Tort?

 

Section 1702 defines serious injury as "a personal injury resulting in death, serious impairment of body function or permanent serious disfigurement."

 

In Washington v. Baxter, decided October 29, 1998, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court set out how to decide whether an impairment is serious. The court asks what body function was impaired and whether that impairment was serious, looking at the extent of the impairment, how long it lasted, the treatment needed to correct it and any other relevant factors. The Court also held that the question goes to a jury unless reasonable minds could not differ.

 

That makes medical documentation central. Records that show how an injury limited work, sleep, driving, lifting or daily routines, and for how long, are what a jury would weigh.

 

When Can a Limited Tort Driver Still Recover Pain and Suffering?

 

Section 1705(d) lists situations where a limited tort insured is treated as full tort for that claim. They apply when the person causing the injury:

 

  • Is convicted of, or accepts ARD for, driving under the influence of alcohol or a controlled substance in that accident

  • Is operating a motor vehicle registered in another state

  • Intends to injure themselves or another person

  • Does not carry the financial responsibility Pennsylvania requires

 

The exceptions also apply when the limited tort insured:

 

  • Is injured while an occupant of a motor vehicle other than a private passenger motor vehicle

  • Is injured by a vehicle defect caused by the manufacturer or a person servicing the vehicle

 

The occupant exception turns on a definition. Section 1702 describes a private passenger motor vehicle as a four-wheel vehicle insured by a person that is a passenger car not used for hire, or a vehicle with a gross weight up to 9,000 pounds not principally used for commercial purposes other than farming. Riding in a vehicle outside that definition can change the analysis.

 

For more on how DUI cases move through the courts, including ARD, see our post on DUI penalties in Pennsylvania.

 

Who Does Your Tort Choice Cover?

 

Your tort election reaches beyond you. Under 1705(c), the option you pick applies to all insureds under your private passenger policy who are not named insureds on another private passenger policy. That can include a spouse, relatives living in your household and minors in your custody.

 

In practice, a teenager who lives at home and has no policy of their own is usually bound by the parent's tort choice. If you pick limited tort to save money, you are also making that choice for the people in your household who fall under your policy.

 

How Should You Choose Between Limited and Full Tort?

 

Start by finding your current election. Your policy documents or your insurance agent can confirm which option you have.

 

Then weigh a few questions:

 

  • How much is the price difference? The Insurance Department describes limited tort savings as significant but gives no set percentage, so get a quote for both.

  • Who is on your policy? Your choice covers household members without their own policies.

  • How much do you drive, and where? More time on the road means more exposure to a crash with another driver.

  • What else is on the policy? Pennsylvania requires only minimum coverages, which the Insurance Department lists as $5,000 in medical benefits, $15,000 per person and $30,000 per accident in bodily injury liability, and $5,000 in property damage liability. Optional uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage can matter as much as the tort choice.

 

What If You Are Already Hurt and Have Limited Tort?

 

Do not assume you have no claim. Check each exception above against the facts of your crash, including whether the other driver was charged with DUI, where their vehicle was registered and what you were riding in.

 

Next, document your injury thoroughly and consistently. Follow through with treatment and keep notes on how the injury affects daily life.

 

Watch the clock as well. Our post on how long you have to file an injury claim in Pennsylvania covers the two-year deadline, and our post on how comparative negligence works explains how shared fault affects a recovery. For the steps to take right after a collision, see what to do after a car accident in Pennsylvania.

 

FAQ

 

What happens if I never signed a tort election form?

 

The notice required by 75 Pa.C.S. 1705(a) states that if you do not sign and return it, you are considered to have chosen full tort and are charged the full tort premium.

 

Can I recover my medical bills with limited tort?

 

Yes. Limited tort restricts pain and suffering and other nonmonetary damages, not medical and other out-of-pocket expenses.

 

Does limited tort apply if the other driver gets ARD for DUI?

 

No. Section 1705(d) treats you as full tort if the at-fault driver is convicted of DUI or accepts ARD for DUI.

 

Who decides whether my injury is serious?

 

A jury, in most cases. In Washington v. Baxter (1998), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that the issue goes to the jury unless reasonable minds could not differ.

 

Is limited tort cheaper?

 

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department says limited tort offers significant premium savings. The actual difference depends on your insurer and policy, so compare quotes.

 

Does my tort choice affect my kids?

 

It can. Under 1705(c), your election applies to relatives in your household and minors in your custody who are not named insureds on their own policies.

 

Talk to a Personal Injury Attorney at Bolkovac Law Offices

 

Bolkovac Law Offices handles car accident and personal injury claims across Western Pennsylvania from offices in Greensburg, Indiana, Murrysville and Uniontown. Attorney Mark D. Bolkovac, who started and manages the firm, was admitted to practice in Pennsylvania in 2002. Personal injury cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, so you do not pay attorney fees unless the firm recovers compensation for you, and consultations are free. Learn more about our auto accident representation and our personal injury practice.

 

Visit Bolkovac Law Offices or call 724-837-2626 today. Contact us for more information.

 

The information in this article is for general information purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different and outcomes depend on the specific facts involved. To discuss your situation, contact Bolkovac Law Offices at 724-837-2626.

 

Bolkovac Law Offices - Footer Image

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page